The time I had a blind date with an eye doctor


‘A Cinderella Story. Involving an actual cinder’

My friend Mary Ann said she liked the Forbes story (which was about a honeymoon) and the de Kooning story (which was about a living room), but that the story she really wanted to read would be the one about how The Dude and I met.

And I’m going to tell it. But first I have to set the stage a bit.

See, back in the 80s when this tale takes place, I went out a lot. With a lot of different guys. Trust me, this wasn’t at all unusual at the time. Most of my friends also went out with lots of guys. Young People then were not so into that going-out-in-packs thing, much less that thing called ‘hooking up’. (I’m not sure I know exactly what that means, and I don’t want to know. And please don’t mention Tinder.) True, there were a few couples into that serial-monogamy thing, but most of them were married.

A bevy of pre-dating-app beauties. The one on the right (me, hah) has a role in this story

A bevy of pre-dating-app beauties. The one on the right (me, hah) gets the fateful cinder in her eye

So. During the day I’m having a blast working at Ogilvy. Nights and weekends, I’m having a blast going out with guys. Let’s see, at the time of this story I was going out with a blonde surfer-type guy from California, an energetic older guy (he was probably 45) I met running in Central Park, a hunky television producer who owned his own Personal Truck, and, oh, off and on I was also seeing a Russian waiter. I’m not counting Steve Martin. I met him a week after I met The Dude. (If you have a sec, you can read that story here. It’s a pretty good one.)

I was also doing a lot of running in those days. As in, training for marathons. (Don’t worry; I’m not going to bore you with marathon stories. At least not right now.)

One fateful day while running on the bridle path in Central Park I managed to get a cinder in my eye. I couldn’t get it out myself, so when I got to work, I went to the nurse. (Yes, Ogilvy had an on-site nurse; she was called Nurse Penny.)

Nurse Penny couldn’t get it out either, so she sent me to an ophthalmologist on the Upper East Side. (Now, this story would be even better if the Ophthalmologist in Question had been Dr. Dude, but nope. His name was Dr. Bloomfield.)

So Dr. B is probing around in my eye, chasing said cinder. He’s also asking a lot of questions. Like ‘are you married?’ (‘nope’) ‘are you engaged?’ (‘uh-uh’) ‘are you seeing anybody special?’ (‘got an hour?’) I’m starting to feel a tad uncomfortable, since his giant gold wedding band keeps glinting its way into my line of cinder-blocked vision, when he says ‘oh! I’m not asking for myself.’  (‘whew’) ‘I have this doctor friend I think would really like to meet you.’

Well. Seeing as how I didn’t have any doctors in my lineup, I say ‘sure, I’d be happy to meet him’. I’m still helpless in the big poofy patient chair when Dr. B grabs his desk phone, punches in a number, says ‘Hello, Dude’s Real Name, I have someone here just perfect for you’, and hands the phone to me.

‘Um, hello?’ I manage, and the next thing you know this Mystery Doctor and I have made an arrangement to meet for dinner at this sushi place he knew. (We did have an ‘escape clause’; if we didn’t hit it off we’d leave after one drink.)

This was a blind date (with an eye doctor, hah), so how would he know me? I told him I’d be wearing white, thinking that would do it. Well, this was August. Do you have any idea how many women wear white in New York in August? About as many as wear black any other time of year. The Dude told me later that his head snapped around every time some woman walked in wearing white. Sometimes he wanted to hide under the table.

Hubba hubba. The Dude, sans white Doctor Coat, at about the time of this story

Hubba hubba. The Dude, wearing a pearly-white smile and not much else — definitely not his white doctor coat — at about the time of this story

But we met, we clicked. And the surfer and the old guy, the producer and the Russian waiter, and yes, even Steve Martin, all vanished into the mists of dating history.

The Dude and I were at a party once when someone asked how we met. I had just gotten to the part about Dr. B handing me the phone and saying ‘I have someone here just perfect for you’ when His Dudeness interjects ‘Oh, yes. He did that all the time. He must have introduced me to a dozen girls.’


New York City. April 2016

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

38 thoughts on “The time I had a blind date with an eye doctor

  1. That is a lovely story. Everything happens for a reason doesn’t it. Just think, without the cinder in the eye you wouldn’t have met The Dude. If Nurse Penny had managed to get the cinder out you may have married her! Well maybe not…..

  2. drallisonbrown

    Great story! I, too, believe that people are brought into our lives at the right time, for the right reason. My husband and I have been married for 28 years, and he has always said he absolutely knew we were meant to be together (it took me a bit longer to realize, however). I wrote about it in my McDonald’s blog – you may have already seen it.

  3. Unbound Roots

    Thank you for sharing your lovely story! Everything does happen for a reason, doesn’t it? Congrats on your long and happy marriage. My husband and I were high school sweethearts, have been together for 22 years and married for 12. I believe “we” happened for a reason too. 🙂

  4. What a great story! Makes you wonder if things happen for a reason. Good thing you got that cinder in your eye. Good thing the nurse at Ogilvy couldn’t get it out. Good thing she sent you Dr. B. Good thing he was introducing every girl he met to The Dude. Good thing he answered the phone 🙂

    • Hey thanks, Stomperdad! Yup, stories like these are what makes one believe in Fate. ‘For want of a cinder, The Dude was lost’ — that kind of thing!

    • Hey, thanks K. Renae! And every word is true. Speaking of ‘true’, I didn’t know that mice can’t burp. (Not to mention that horses can’t barf) Interesting stuff, yours!

  5. Wise choice (although I think wisdom had very little to do with it) for “hooking up” and staying hooked up with The Dude. Love is a wonderful thing, as well as compatibility and loyalty and all that. Thanks, Alice.

  6. Alice, this is every bit as wonderful as I could have imagined it would be. I have been have issues with my eyes lately, maybe I should make an appointment with Dr. Bloomfield. I’d like to think that he could also help in the relationship department, but all age appropriate men are already dead.

    • So glad you enjoyed this one, Mary Ann. (And thanks again for the suggestion!) As for your eyes, an appointment with a cute doc is a good idea. Dr. Bloomfield, alas, has passed on to the Great Eyechart in the Sky. But The Dude would see you any ole time. xo

  7. Holly Hooper

    Why didn’t you tell me you had a blog? Hilarious and adorable! Steve Martin? I wanted to marry Steve Martin when I was 12….figured I would be happily entertained and rolling with laughter for the rest of my life with him. Do dish….

    • Gee thanks, Holly. And welcome to my blog. I used to tell everyone I met that I had a blog, then people started running when they saw me coming (!) Yes, Steve was a really nice guy. Too bad he met that woman he eventually got divorced from when he was on that movie promo tour. But then again I wouldn’t have married The Dude, and The Child wouldn’t exist. And so on and so on. xoxo!

I'd love to hear from you